The recent false earthquake warning issued in California raised important questions about the reliability of warning systems that people depend on for their safety.

This warning was for an earthquake measured at 5.9 on the border of California and Nevada and was later confirmed to be incorrect. Although no damage occurred, the public was left in a state of shock, prompting lawmakers to ask crucial questions.

The warning was disseminated via ShakeAlert, an earthquake early warning system operated by the United States Geological Survey (USGS). ShakeAlert is designed to detect seismic activity and provide people in the area with a few seconds of warning before strong shaking begins.

However, on December 4, 2025, cell phones across California, including regions hundreds of miles away from the reported earthquake’s location, rang with alerts. Shortly thereafter, the earthquake details were removed from the USGS website, which stated that the alert had been sent out in error.

California lawmakers are demanding more information regarding the cause of the incorrect warning and mechanisms to ensure that such a mistake does not happen again in the future.

U.S. Representative Kevin Mullin and four other members of Congress emphasized that public trust in the USGS is vital during emergencies. They believe that people need real-time information from federal agencies in cases of life-threatening disasters, such as earthquakes.

The false alert quickly became a political issue. California Governor Gavin Newsom suggested that budget cuts and staff layoffs contributed to the incident. In contrast, the Department of the Interior argued that it was a technical error that had been promptly resolved.

Critics accused Governor Newsom of politicizing a technical issue that could occur regardless of funding or administration. To investigate the cause of the mistake, researchers indicated that a likely reason for the warning was a problem with the power system at a seismic station in Nevada.

Experts stated that a faulty power system generated a large amount of information, even though it was supposed to be automatically rejected. To ensure safety, some stations in Nevada were temporarily disconnected from the ShakeAlert system while investigations were conducted.

Experts noted that this is the first false message from ShakeAlert since its inception in 2019, showcasing its overall reliability, despite the need for some improvements.

This particular event serves as a reminder that emergency technology solutions must be regularly checked and updated to ensure accuracy.

<Ayla S. Lee PV 페닌슐라 고교 10학년>